重製版與原版遊戲究竟誰好，向來是個飽受爭議的話題。近日，推特上一則關於《惡魔之魂》原版和重製版哪個更出色的討論帖，引發了廣大玩家的熱烈討論。這款遊戲的原作是由FS社打造，而重製版則出自Bluepoint之手。其實，這樣的討論在重製版發行之際就曾掀起過熱議。
發帖人@elbethium表示：《惡魔之魂：重製版》在各個維度上都超越了原版。無論是遊戲畫面精美質感、操作手感和流暢體驗，還是玩法上的創新（例如全方位閃避），重製版都表現得更為出色。那些聲稱重製版「毀了原作」的人，並非展現出自己作為資深玩家的睿智，反而顯得像個固執的孩子。
Demon's Souls Remake
— Elbethium (@elbethium) October 16, 2025
Is superior to the OG game in every way possible. The game looks, feels and plays(like the omidirectional dodging) BETTER.
Saying they "butchered it" , doesnt give you some wise veteran status, it makes you look like a stubborn child. pic.twitter.com/wp9k0miqo3
在討論中，支持重製版更優的玩家覺得，重製版所帶來的體驗相當不錯，能讓大家有動力玩下去就已經很值得肯定了。而傾向於原版更好的多數玩家則認為，原版的藝術設計和營造出的獨特遊戲氛圍才是其精髓所在，可惜重製版在這方面沒有很好地汲取原版的優點，實在令人可惜，所以他們才更支持原版。
I played Demons Souls on the ps3 I was not really into it much back them, but I made to half way through until my ps3 disc drive died. Thankfully Iwas able to pick it up on the ps5 and I don't understand the hate at all. For me the whole experience after was really great. pic.twitter.com/tkD160GL2I
— Cristian Matos (@CristianMatos03) October 16, 2025
It's okay that you PREFER it, but liking its gameplay doesn't make it a superior project on the whole. pic.twitter.com/n4jLchDOFi
— 🌙 (@zero_xof) October 17, 2025
對於諸如「重製版不過是畫面有所提升，其他方面並無特別之處」這類言論，帖主回應稱，遊戲重製版在諸多現代機制上進行了調整，還有很多值得稱讚的亮點，並非只是徒有其表。
No it isnt exactly the same game, the MP has been reworked to match modern souls games, and many mechanical tweaks like the omnidirectional dodging.
— Elbethium (@elbethium) October 16, 2025
DeS is a game that had no idea what it wanted to be, and is no wonder with development hell it was in. pic.twitter.com/59PwxPjGkF
